deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

:iconcjwilde:
This is an interesting piece. I shall be honest, and say first off that I am still relatively unsure of your concept and meaning with this poem - I didn't entirely understand what you wanted me to feel, or what you were trying to evoke in me as the reader - but one is meant to take their own personal interpretation of a poem, and for me, this piece was about someone who was punishing themselves for feeling lust towards a forbidden person; probably a friend. A sensation of lust, for an act of trust was my clue for this.

Grammatically, I would like to make a few points if you don't mind. Firstly, although the rhythm was fairly sound in the rest of the poem, I felt the first stanza was choppy and the constant pauses due to the periods at the end of each line put me off rather a lot. I feel it reads a lot better and smoother with them removed. In the second stanza I noticed a misspell; Misstress should be 'Mistress'. I liked this line, however. It was powerful and the way it felt as though it should be shouted reminded me strongly of the Phantom of the Opera, for some reason. :aww:

Towards the end of the piece, I felt the period at the end of making faces at was very unnecessary and made it initially difficult to understand that line, assuming it continues into My selfish pity. Here, I would like to ask the meaning of the words. Although 'selfish' made a lot of sense and was relevant to my interpretation, who do you pity? Do you pity yourself, after torturing yourself for wanting a person you cannot have; but if that is the case, why would it be selfish?

I am sorry if I seem terribly blunt, or you don't agree with me. Feel free to disregard my thoughts. I did enjoy the piece and found it to be rather dark, and perhaps the mystery you have created here is put to good effect. I look forward to hearing your thoughts. :)
The Artist thought this was FAIR
5 out of 5 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


:iconmissmorticia:
*MissMorticia Mar 11, 2012  Professional General Artist
:worship: I'll be the first to admit that grammar and spelling aren't my strong points (which is slightly ironic for someone who enjoys reading and writing as much as I do). So I really do appreciate all the help I can get in that area, which you always seem to do so beautifully! Oh and I never think your advice is blunt, if anything your comments, I look forward to getting! So no need to apologise in my opinion.

Thank you once again for taking the time to over a piece of mine, I'll be reviewing it in the next few days. :huggle:
Reply
:iconcjwilde:
~CJWilde Mar 12, 2012  Student Writer
I am so glad you appreciate my advice. It always makes me smile to know my thoughts are being put to good use. I look forward to seeing what you do with this piece in the future. :hug:
Reply
:iconcjwilde:
~CJWilde Mar 10, 2012  Student Writer
Once again, I have failed to note that I am here from #Critique-It's Poetry Week (in case you were wondering!) Sorry about that. :aww:
Reply
Add a Comment: